Dutch Court Rejects Chinese Mummy Buddha Repatriation Case
Fahad Shabbir (@FahadShabbir) Published December 13, 2018 | 04:04 PM
An Amsterdam court ruled on that the mummy Buddha repatriation case filed by two Chinese villages against a Dutch collector is "inadmissible.
AMSTERDAM, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 13th Dec, 2018 ) :An Amsterdam court ruled on that the mummy Buddha repatriation case filed by two Chinese villages against a Dutch collector is "inadmissible." According to the court, it is unclear whether the Chinese village committees have the right to bring legal claims, while the villagers argued that a village committee in China is a "special legal person" under the Chinese civil law.
According to the court, the Chinese law that was invoked by the Chinese villagers had not come into force until Oct. 1, 2017, but "the summons has been issued before that date." "Legal opinions submitted to the court are not unequivocal," said the court. "For instance whether the village committees are actively functioning, and established according to the rules, and since when." "Basically, the claim is rejected as it is according to the court not proven that the committees have the right to bring the claim according to Chinese law," said Jan Holthuis, a Dutch lawyer representing the villagers.
"I find this decision hard to digest," said Holthuis. "Because the village committees did bring a claim before the Chinese courts before October 1, 2017, which proves they have legal standing." "Very disappointing. The court also did not ask anything in this respect during the last hearing," he added.
"So we will advise the villagers to appeal this judgement." Yushen Liu, a Beijing-based lawyer who assists in this case, told Xinhua that a village committee is fully entitled to bring legal claims in China.
"We submitted opinions from legal experts especially addressing the legal status of village committees to explain the situation in detail," he said. "It might be difficult for judges in other countries to have a clear understanding of this. This problem can and must be solved through appeal." In May 2016, two villages in China's southeastern province of Fujian filed this repatriation case of religious, cultural and ethical significance against Amsterdam inhabitant Oscar van Overeem,They believe that the statue Van Overeem lent for an exhibition in March 2015 was the one that their villages had worshipped for over 1,000 years before it was stolen from the village temple in December 1995.
Van Overeem agrees that the statue comes from the province of Fujian, but insists that it is not the "Zhanggong Monk Master" as claimed by the villagers. He said that he had exchanged the statue for another artwork with a third party who prefers to remain anonymous. Two public hearings were held in July 2017 and last October.
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Currency Rate In Pakistan - Dollar, Euro, Pound, Riyal Rates On 26 April 2024
Today Gold Rate in Pakistan 26 April 2024
ICC Womens T20 World Cup Qualifier, Match 2: Ireland Women open with Comfortable ..
Robinson, bowlers help New Zealand go 2-1 up against Pakistan
Shahzeb Chachar to hold khuli kachehri on April 26
Heatwave amid Israel's aggression in Gaza brings new misery, disease risk
Tourism must change, mayor says as Venice launches entry fee
Court adjourns Judicial Complex attack case till May 17
Nasreen Noori’s book ‘Popatan Jahra Khwab’ launched
Wafaqi Mohtasib inspection team visits Excise and taxation office
AJLAC announces 5th Conference titled ‘People’s Mandate: Safeguarding Civil ..
Pak-US officials engage to enhance trade, investment ties
More Stories From World
-
United by grief, families of Boeing crash victims demand justice
4 minutes ago -
Microsoft expands its AI empire abroad
14 minutes ago -
China ready to work with Pakistan to promote practical cooperation under CPEC, GDI: Luo Zhaohui
14 minutes ago -
Nuggets push Lakers to brink as Embiid's 50 points lead Sixers over Knicks
24 minutes ago -
Man City in title groove as Arsenal face Spurs test
24 minutes ago -
Philippine settlement submerged by dam reappears due to drought
24 minutes ago
-
ByteDance says 'no plans' to sell TikTok after US ban law
1 hour ago -
Oil: 'Mother of corruption' in Venezuela
1 hour ago -
ECO General Secretary urges member nations to embrace cultural wealth
1 hour ago -
China warns Blinken over deteriorating ties in talks
1 hour ago -
Famine-threatened Sudan's 'race against time' to plant crops
1 hour ago -
Microsoft, Google earnings shine as AI drives revenue
2 hours ago