Missionaries Seen As Asset, But Sometimes Headache, By US
Muhammad Irfan Published October 19, 2021 | 09:40 AM
Washington, (UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 19th Oct, 2021 ) :The kidnapping of 17 missionaries in Haiti reinforces a predicament for Washington -- religious groups are often seen as an asset, going where many don't dare, but they can also find themselves in deep trouble.
Gangs that brazenly rule much of the Western Hemisphere's poorest nation over the weekend abducted 17 US and Canadian missionaries including children, the latest attack that appeared aimed at raising ransom money.
The United States had already issued its highest-level warning against travel to Haiti.
But religious groups, who believe they are doing God's work, are also frontline partners when the United States needs a presence in the world's most dangerous places.
Since the presidency of George W. Bush, the United States has channelled a growing amount of foreign aid to faith-based groups, a once controversial practice that has become largely accepted across administrations.
Religious charities have long roots in Haiti, where the abducted missionaries came from Christian Aid Ministries, an Ohio-based organization of Mennonites and Amish.
"If you want to help set up clinics in South Sudan or Haiti, you don't do it with the government, you do it with an NGO," said Melani McAlister, a professor of American studies at George Washington University.
"And American religious groups are absolutely a major, important part of that network of NGOs," she said.
Todd Johnson, co-director of the Center for the Study of Global Christianity at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, said that long-term missionaries generally develop the language skills and cultural knowledge -- as well as proper paperwork -- to operate effectively.
"It's to the US government's advantage that they succeed," he said.
He said there should be no difference in the government's response if the abducted people are missionaries or, for example, businesspeople held for money.
- Viewed 'as a problem' - The State Department says it treats missionaries no differently than it would other US citizens who need help overseas.
But missionaries have frequently triggered major diplomatic incidents.
Knox Thames, a former State Department official focused on international religious freedom, said that US diplomats were often unaware of missionaries, who have no obligation to share their beliefs or whereabouts.
"However, American embassies often view missionaries as a problem," he said.
"They might offend local sensibilities, run afoul of anti-proselytizing laws or find themselves kidnapped like in Haiti." The Islamic world is especially sensitive about conversion attempts. In one high-profile case, 23 Christian missionaries from South Korea were abducted in 2007 by the Taliban in Afghanistan, freed only after Seoul agreed to withdraw troops from the US-led mission.
Among US citizens, Turkey's arrest during a nationwide crackdown of Andrew Brunson, a pastor who had been a resident for years and had become a cause celebre in evangelical Christian circles, led former president Donald Trump in 2018 to raise tariffs to secure his release.
Russia has faced US criticism for a ban on most missionaries. Minefields exist even with friendly nations such as India, which allows foreign missionaries to enter only if they do not proselytize.
Missionaries can also find themselves far from help as in the case of John Chau, the American who was killed in 2018 by an isolated tribal group as he sought to bring Christianity to a remote Indian island in the Andaman Sea.
The kidnapped Mennonites were not believed to be seeking converts in Haiti, a country that is already largely Christian, albeit Catholic.
But proselytization is an integral part of faith to many American Christians, notably members of the Church of Jesus Christ and Latter-Day Saints, which encourages young men to work overseas as missionaries.
According to the church, some 54,000 missionaries served around the world last year, with fresh-faced, clean-cut young men on street corners sometimes becoming foreigners' first encounters with Americans.
The US government, while partnering with faith groups, says it provides funding only for aid and not for proselytizing.
Johnson, the scholar of missionaries, said that most Christians were fine with that.
"Ninety percent -- maybe more -- of Christian aid and development is very sensitive to proselytizing, because it just doesn't work well," he said.
"From a Christian point of view, it's part of Christian witness to simply help people," he said. "If people are interested in more than that, that's good, but if they just help that's fine as well."
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Tennis: ATP Barcelona Open results - 1st update
Swiatek's perfect 10 in Stuttgart as Vondrousova stuns Sabalenka
Arandu's roads closed due to flooding
Oil tanker catches fire in Islamabad’s Blue Area
Pakistan committed to ensure safety of foreign nationals: FO
Tennis: WTA Stuttgart results - 1st update
Four passengers injured as train hit an empty vehicle
Over- speeding bus crushed to death two bike riders
Turkey's Freedom Flotilla ready to set sail for Gaza
French teen dies from heart failure after knife attack near school
Iranians appear unfazed by Isfahan blasts
UAF celebrates Int'l Chinese Language Day
More Stories From Miscellaneous
-
Transforming education sector: from job hunters to job creators
21 hours ago -
Amjad Bobby remembered on 19th death anniversary for timeless contributions to music
5 days ago -
Legendary actor Nadeem’s 26 films released on Eid-ul-Fitr days in 50 years
6 days ago -
Besant Hall Cultural Centre to celebrate evening with Sanam Marvi on 26 April
6 days ago -
Radio Bahawalpur presents program “Eidi Shidi”
9 days ago -
Radio Bahawalpur to broadcast Eid programs
11 days ago
-
DC, DPO Haripur inspect bus terminals to review fares compliance
13 days ago -
Second phase of refugees’ repatriation to start after Eidul Fitr vacations
13 days ago -
Reaping bounties as Ramazan culminates
13 days ago -
Digital transformation – a boon or bane
13 days ago -
Plants’ business: Another casualty of climate change
15 days ago -
Eid shoppers prioritize children’s joy over personal comforts
15 days ago