US Judge Blocks Lethal Injection Drug Combo As Unlawful
Mohammad Ali (@ChaudhryMAli88) Published January 27, 2017 | 02:05 AM
CHICAGO, (APP - UrduPoint / Pakistan Point News - 27th Jan, 2017 ) : Citing mounting evidence from recent US executions, a federal judge blocked Thursday the use of lethal injections to put to death three Ohio inmates, saying a proposed drug cocktail was unconstitutional.
Federal Magistrate Judge Michael Merz of Ohio focused heavily on the use of one of the drugs, midazolam, citing evidence from multiple other state executions that the drug insufficiently sedated inmates, likely leading to suffering during their executions.
Lawyers for the three Ohio inmates claimed such suffering violated the US Constitution's Eighth Amendment prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment. Judge Merz sided with that argument, saying the proposed three-drug lethal injection cocktail "creates a substantial risk of serious harms." Raymond Tibbetts, Ronald Phillips and Gary Otte were scheduled to be executed by Ohio between February and April, but Merz granted a preliminary injunction barring the state from using a combination of midazolam, to be followed by a paralytic agent and potassium chloride, which stops the heart.
In a 119-page ruling, the judge cited recent executions in Ohio, Alabama, Arizona and elsewhere, where inmates receiving midazolam as the first drug in a lethal injection cocktail appeared to remain conscious for a substantial period of time.
Ohio halted executions after the 2014 lethal injection of Dennis McGuire using midazolam, during which the inmate appeared to snort and gasp.
Judge Merz pointed to witness testimony from that execution, including from Columbus Dispatch reporter Alan Johnson, who has witnessed 20 executions in total.
"McGuire began coughing, gasping, choking in a way that I had not seen before at any execution... Frankly, that went on for 12 to 13 minutes," the judge quoted Johnson as saying. The state countered that the revised dosage of midazolam would be 50 times stronger.
But the judge pointed to expert testimony offered by the plaintiffs that midazolam was not an adequate substitute for general anesthesia drugs. Its use in executions is "contrary to sound medical or scientific reasoning," testified Craig Stevens, professor of pharmacology at Oklahoma State University, according to the court.
States have struggled to find adequate supplies of lethal injection drugs, as pharmaceutical companies have restricted the use of their drugs for executions. Court challenges have ensued as states have tried new drug cocktails.
"This ruling brings Ohio in line with recent developments from other states that have recognized that midazolam is not an appropriate drug for use in executions," said Megan McCracken of the Death Penalty Clinic at the University of California, Berkeley.
"The risks of extraordinary pain and suffering with this protocol are unconstitutional, and this ruling correctly recognizes the problems with midazolam."
Related Topics
Recent Stories
Mired in crisis, Boeing reports another loss
Session Awarding Ceremony 2024 held at Cadet College Muzaffarabad
Austrian ski great Hirscher to make comeback under Dutch flag
Pakistan, Japan agrees to convene 'Economic Policy Dialogue'
FM Dar conveys deepest sympathy on torrential rains devastation in UAE
Spain PM Sanchez says weighing resignation after wife's graft probe
Tennis: ATP/WTA Madrid Open results - 1st update
Long-lost Klimt portrait auctioned off for 30 mn euros
Osaka seals first win on clay since 2022 in Madrid
Earthquake jolts Karachi
Sindh minister orders operation after attack on police in Ghotki
TikTok to fight US ban law in courts
More Stories From World
-
Football: English Championship table
4 hours ago -
Time for 'democratic transition' in Venezuela: opposition candidate to AFP
4 hours ago -
Spain's Pedro Sanchez : a risk-taker with a flair for survival
4 hours ago -
Football: French Ligue 1 table
5 hours ago -
Nadal will only play French Open if he can 'compete well'
5 hours ago -
Ukraine, Israel, TikTok: the massive aid package before US Congress
5 hours ago
-
TikTok to fight US ban law in courts
5 hours ago -
Football: French Ligue 1 results
5 hours ago -
Spain PM Sanchez says weighing resignation after wife's graft probe
6 hours ago -
Long-lost Klimt portrait auctioned off for 30 mn euros
6 hours ago -
TikTok to fight US ban law in courts
6 hours ago -
Anger among Ukrainians in Poland as Kyiv halts passport renewals
6 hours ago